Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Binker

The Aftermath

Recommended Posts

A friend of mine read this and enjoyed it, so I decided to read it.  I liked the same things she liked and was put off by the same things that put her off.  

 

The book tells the story of the rebuilding of Hamburg after WWII.  An officer in the British Army, Lewis Morgan, in charge of rebuilding Hamburg is billeted in a tremendous mansion on the River Elbe.  He is permitted to kick out the owner and his daughter, who are living there (his wife has been killed in a British bombing raid on Hamburg), but decides not to do it.  It's an enormous house and they can live in the servants quarters while he and his wife and surviving child (one son was killed by a German bombing raid) can live in the main part of the house.  Their servants can stay, too.  

 

Lewis's efforts are extremely nice--the family would have had to live homelessly or in refugee camps and the servants might have lost their jobs, too.  No one thinks Lewis should do this for the family.  The father of the German family, Stefan Lubert, recognizes that he is being treated as kindly as circumstances permit, but his 15-year-old daughter doesn't quite see it that way, holding on to her hatred of the British.  

 

You can imagine that this sets up all sorts of tensions in the household and where they lead and don't lead.  This was interesting and somewhat engaging, given my very limited tolerance for love stories.  For the most part, it's well-handled, but there's a bit too much coincidence to keep me happy.

 

What was fascinating was the glimpse into what it was really like.  The city was just destroyed in parts.  I always marvel at how cities that are bombed recover as quickly as they do.  Stefan is an architect and his description of what he sees in the future for his city is very engaging.  I imagine that something like what he wanted to do is what actually happened and someone had to do that.  Very interesting.

 

But the lives before all this rebuilding are so very grim.  People starve to death.  The coldest winter on record adds to the misery.  So many people are displaced that there are groups of people wearing signs with pictures hoping to reconnect with lost loved ones and a whole wall where these signs are posted.  I remember that something like that happened on a much smaller scale after the September 11 attacks.  There are roving bands of children who are orphaned and do everything they can to eat and find shelter.  That reminded me of The Painted Bird, a book I would rather not be reminded of reading.  

 

And finally, individual Germans had to be determined to be "white, grey, or black" depending on their involvement with the Nazi party.  I hadn't realized that had happened, but of course it did.  The uniformed comments of the British about the people they meet in Hamburg, judging them for the accommodations they had to make to a totalitarian system, were probably what everyone thought, Lewis excepted.  He and his son, and eventually his wife, have to struggle to rid themselves of their preconceived notions so that they can interact with the Germans they encounter on a daily basis as fellow human beings.  I particularly liked the efforts of Lewis's son, Ed and how he tries to make sense of what he encounters. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I read this: I thought I had posted on it, but maybe not.

Like you, Binker, I think I enjoyed the subject matter more than the actual book. I saw an exhibition a few years ago in the German Historical Museum in Berlin about Germany after the war, and I was gobsmacked by what I found out.

 

Last year, I got talking to a friend of mine who fled the Sudetenland as a kid. I have known him for years and had never listened to his stories, but this time I did and it was fascinating.

 

Anyway, it's a fairly good book, isn't it? I think it was based on something that had happened in his own family.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 That reminded me of The Painted Bird, a book I would rather not be reminded of reading.  

 

 

Couldn't agree with you more!  I can't remember many of the details of The Painted Bird, fortunately, but I remember the effect it had on me well.

 

I've had The Aftermath sort-of on my wish list for some time, I couldn't make up my mind whether I wanted to read it or not.  From your review I think it might go on the "I'll be happy to borrow it but probably wouldn't buy it" list.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It was based on a real life arrangement.  The author's grandfather did this after WWII for 5 years!  I don't think all the other complications are true--the author just took what was admittedly an unusual arrangement and ran with it.  

 

I thought it was a good book and might move even seek it out from the library.  It was a very interesting picture into an experience--post-war rebuilding--that I wasn't very familiar with contained in a story that was entertaining.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's 1946, Germany is in ruins, the people are starving and the country is occupied by allied troops. Rachel Morgan, still grieving for her elder son, killed by a stray bomb, arrives in Hamburg with her younger son to rejoin her husband, a British colonel in charge of the regeneration of the area. They have been allocated a requisitioned house and she discovers to her dismay that her husband has agreed to allow the German owners, the Lauberts,  to continue living there in the upstairs staff flat.

 

The true strengths of this book are the pictures it draws of the period, the hardships suffered by the populace and the almost impossible task men like Lewis Morgan had in trying to make things better.  I already knew a certain amount about the Army of Occupation - both my parents were in Germany then (married to others) and my mother told me quite a lot about it but this was a real eye opener. 

 

Some parts of the story line are a bit clichéd, especially the mirror imaging of loss, The Morgan's have lost a son, the Lauberts a wife and mother who died in the firestorm of Hamburg. In both cases it's the women, Rachel and Frieda Laubert,  aged 15, who don't try to forgive and accept, and the men,  are the ones making contact with the other side. That apart I thoroughly enjoyed it, it's not perfect but it's one of those books whivh is going to stay with me for a very lng time.  Reccommended.

 

I did find this book a little slow at the beginning - literally. I loved the prose from the start but was always surprised at how little I'd read.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I read this a while ago - I liked it too.

That period of German history interests me a lot. I went to an exhibition on the subject in the Deutsches Historisches Museum in Berlin and it was an eye opener. I hadn't realised how desperate things were in Germany in the immediate post war years, and how the Germans felt they deserved this deprivation for their war crimes. Also, as the novel shows, getting the "Persilschein" to prove you weren't tainted by Nazism was open to corruption. It was a really interesting novel, based on a true story I think.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, Minxminnie said:

I just searched too, for Aftermath, Rhidian, and Brook. Only got this thread on the title. So useless.

But if you look at the bottom of the page MM you'll see the link to the thread started by Binker  - which we both replied to!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Threads merged.

If you had clicked on the red 'author' tag at the top of the thread t would have brought up all the threads on Rhidian Brook's title -  which seemed to consist only of the two on The Aftermath.

I wonder what happened to The Testimony of Taliesin Jones, and Jesus and the Adman, both of which I am sure I started threads on, but so long ago they probably got lost in one of the historic forum crashes?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think there's now a movie made from this book.  It probably emphasizes the love story aspect, which means I won't want to see it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 28/01/2019 at 16:27, Binker said:

I think there's now a movie made from this book.  It probably emphasizes the love story aspect, which means I won't want to see it.

Judging by the reviews you're absolutely right.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Similar Content

    • By Binker
      I read this book on vacation and then came back to a whirlwind of work and taking our son to college, so am just now posting a review. 
       
      The book follows the police efforts of Woodrow Cain, a young policeman from North Carolina who has relocated to New York City in 1942 with the help of his father-in-law after his wife leaves him. Cain is clearly an outsider--others in the department mock his accent and his small-town experience.  What they are missing, though, is that Cain is a tenacious and intuitive police officer.   They should have been paying closer attention because almost immediately Cain is sent to investigate the first death in a case that has significant repercussions in the police department and other parts of New York officialdom.  It appears that no one expected him to be successful and are unhappily surprised when he makes progress.
       
      He's helped in his progress by an old man who calls himself Danziger.  Danziger makes his living reading and writing letters between immigrants in New York and their family and friends back home.  Many of them are Jewish and so more and more frequently, the letters from the people in New York to Europe go unanswered.  It is very touching to hear him describe the services he provides and the sadness of not knowing, but strongly suspecting, what has happened to the recipients of the letters.  "Their relations in Prague have fallen silent.  It has been that way across the whole of the east of Europe for some time now.  Candles flickering to darkness."
       
      Although the main "mystery" is Cain's police case, Danziger is "The Letter Writer" and to me, he seemed to be the hero of the story.  You end up with a great deal of affection for both of them and are particularly pleased at the piece of information that gives Danziger hope at the end, although it's a little too neat.  Interestingly, the resolution of Cain's mystery is based on events that really occurred at the time, so I can't accuse that part of the story of being too neat.  
       
      I enjoyed this book very much and have recommended it to others who also enjoyed it.  
    • By Binker
      I've read everything that Alan Furst has written.  His first books were perfection and then he had sort of a less-good period. This book, however, was great.  It reminded me of why I liked his earlier books so much.  
       
      This book tells the story of a man we know as Mathieu, a leader of the French Resistance, whose cell is devoted to spiriting British pilots who have experienced an emergency landing in France back to their home.  It's late in the war and pilots have been dying like flies, so it's critically important that these pilots get back to fly more missions.  
       
      The book shows the clever plans of the cell, how they accomplish those plans, and what dangers they encounter through several vignettes of rescued pilots over a relatively short period of time.  You get to know Mathieu best, but you also get a good feel for some of the other cell members, and even the pilots, who are drawn from all walks of life.  Then the war ends and in the last few pages, you learn who Mathieu was in real life.  
       
      My favorite Alan Furst books are these slice-of-life ones--they feel a bit like short stories.  You know that each of these characters had another life, engaged in Resistance work before the stories in this book, and then went on with their post-war lives afterwards.  So you just see this significant moments in their lives.  My least favorite Furst books involve love affairs and while there was still some of that in this book, there was not too much and it didn't ruin the book for me.
       
      Strongly recommend.
    • By Binker
      This book takes place in familiar Alan Furst territory: Paris right before WWII, when it's clear what's coming, but most people are still trying not to think about it.  
       
      "Most people" includes Cristian Ferrar, a Spanish aristocrat who has relocated his family to Paris to avoid the chaos that was Spain before and during the Civil War.  When we meet him, he's folding up a newspaper and putting it back in his briefcase, "at least for the moment he would spare himself the smoke and fume of Europe on fire."  He's a lawyer, working at a very conservative law firm in Paris. He gets pulled into helping the Republicans arm themselves, which his firm supports tacitly, but makes it clear that he can't embarrass them at all.  His adventures become steadily less straightforward until he is buying arms in Berlin and trying to get them shipped to Spain in the face of many attempts to prevent him from doing so from people who appear to know a good deal more about his movements than he would have preferred.
       
      This book seems more sophisticated to me than many of Furst's books.  Ferrar himself and several other men who have been pulled into the arms efforts identify spies much more quickly than some of Furst's other protagonists (although Ferrar didn't see the danger until long after a reader who is paying attention sees it).  Ferrar is a bit starry-eyed about the Republican side and is shocked when he realizes they've executed someone.  But he's getting more sophisticated about evil, too--when he hears the story, he shakes his head "in sorrow.  He'd heard so many of these stories as Spain tore itself to pieces."  Some people you meet and even like have very sad endings, brought on more by the time and place in which they were living than anything else, which Ferrar understands better by the end of the book than he did at the beginning.  Of course, the saddest ending at this point is in Spain and the book's ending is about as sad and ambiguous an ending as Furst has ever produced.
       
      I have often complained that Furst shouldn't write romance in his books and this time, he controlled himself much better than in other outings, which I liked.  No big emotional entanglements, thank goodness.  
       
      I also enjoyed his language.  The two quotes above so perfectly capture what is must have been like to have been alive and in Europe during that time.  Surely all countries tear themselves to pieces in civil war.  And "smoke and fume" makes me think of images of hell and the devil, which are both very appropriate images for what was about to happen.
       
      So...not quite as good as his earliest books, but much better than some of the middle ones (although even Furst's not-quite-as-good books are engaging reads).  I thought the previous book was very good and this one even better.  I hope Furst continues on this trajectory.
    • By momac
      Am reading about the Coast Watcher's network on the Solomon Islands in WWII - really amazing what these brave people did and endured.

      Alone on Guadalcanal. - Martin Clemens
×