Jump to content

Recommended Posts

This book was published in 1981 and is set in 1977 at a time when the cold war was at its height and little was known about the internal policing of the Soviet Union. What a great place, then to set a detective novel.


The first third of the book appears to be a conventional detective novel involving the investigation into the murder of three bodies found in Gorky Park. Arkady Renko, a chief investigator with the Moscow militia is assigned to the case and his investigations lead him to discover the murderer.


Upon this discovery and Renko's confrontation with the murder, the novel could have ended and it could be considered to be one of the finest crime novels written. However, Martin Cruz Smith takes things further.


After a short interlude of some 26 pages; the location shifts to New York and an attempt to recover the good stolen by the murder, and the reason for the murders. The twists introduced at this late stage and the exploration of motives is brilliant and lists this book from merely great to brilliant.



Link to comment
Share on other sites

I agree. I saw the film first (which I love and use to watch over and over again) and then read the book which was, if anything, even better. It's a pacy, plot driven psychological thriller - but with huge dollops of politics heaped on top. It was the first film/book I had read that seemed to consider everyday life in the USSR rather than just looking at spies and dissidents. I also enjoyed Polar Star, the sequel, although it felt slightly more contrived than Gorky Park.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Martin Cruz Smith is my favorite mystery novelist. I say novelist because I think he aspires to more than simply writing. He is a top-notch Russia watcher, and has had a couple of Russia-themed articles published in National Geographic in the past few years.


I, too, saw the movie before reading this wonderful novel. The only other novel I can compare it to is Presumed Innocent by Scott Turow, as both delve much more deeply into character and society than any other mystery novels I've read--save, perhaps, the espionage novels of John le Carré, the grandmaster himself. Both Gorky Park and Presumed Innocent offer thrills, complexity, and a great deal of knowledge into their respective topics.


The difference between Gorky Park and Smith's other Arkady Renko novels is the the overall length and the prose, both becoming shorter and leaner in subsequent novels. I also think the characterization gets pared down as well. Of the rest of the novels in the series, I liked Havana Bay the best, followed by Wolves Eat Dogs, Polar Star, and then Red Square. I just read Stalin's Ghost (<- link) a few months ago, but that is by far the worst in the series.


If you liked Gorky Park and want to try something else by Smith, I think Rose (<- link), while slightly different, is his other masterpiece.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 11 months later...

Two men and a woman are found dead in the snow in Gorky Park, Moscow. Their faces and fingers have been removed and the men shot to prevent dental identification. Moscow militia Chief Investigator Arkady Renko doesn't really want the case and wants to hand it over to the KGB, even though he doesn't trust them, especially Major Pribluda who turns up at the murder scene.


When he discovers one of the dead is not a Soviet citizen but an American, he seems to have found his excuse. But his boss Iamskoy seems especially keen to keep the investigation going even though he's assigned a men to Arkady's team who appears to be a KGB informer. In the background, Arkady's marriage to a Party loyalist is collapsing, the blow softened when he meets an actress, Irina Asanova, after discovering the dead woman was wearing Irina's skates. What's her connection to the murder victims and to the American businessman Osborne, to whom Arkady is introduced in a KGB bathhouse by Iamskoy?


The ingredients of a good thriller are there - grisly murders, a loner down-at-heel investigator with woman trouble who doesn't do things by the book, chase sequences, evil foreign bad guys, shadowy sinister spies serving their own interests - all present and correct. Cruz Smith has gone to great lengths to give the feel of paranoia and good Cold War novel should have, plus portraying Arkady's endless frustrations with Soviet bureaucracy.


However, I found "Gorky Park" disappointing overall. It all felt a little formulaic to me, plus which I couldn't quite follow Arkady's thought processes and how he made his steps forward in the case, crucial, I think, to a novel of this type. That might just be me, though. I have had the same problem with the John Le Carré novels I've read.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 months later...

I think he is a great crime writer.


Not only are his crime plots good but he also expands his characters and introduces a social and economic context into what he writes.


One of the few crime writers where I buy the books as soon as they are released in hardback. The other must buy authors I also buy are Michael Connelley and James Lee Burke.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Similar Content

    • By Binker
      This is the latest Arkady Renko book by Martin Cruz Smith and it's good in the same way that his other books are good.  Renko has a good heart that leads him into bad situations and not-necessarily-very-good-relationships.  He still observes things that others do not and so ends up solving mysteries that others don't even realize are mysteries.  And Smith still doesn't spoon feed you the conclusions that Renko is reaching, so that sometimes you are surprised by what he says and does (and the results) and sometimes you are not.   
      In this book, an investigative reporter, Tatiana Petrovna, falls to her death at the same time that a mob boss is shot and buried.  Renko is the only person who thinks there might be a connection and of course, he's right.  Everything leads to Kaliningrad, the main city in a little outpost of Russia between Poland and Lithuania that I didn't even know existed despite having read all the Wallender books and, I thought, really learning the geography of the area.  Kaliningrad is apparently the location of secret meetings that absolutely must remain secret, but which require the services of a translator.  The translator also goes missing along with his book in which he "describes" the meeting in his own idiosyncratic notes and symbols.  This book travels around and once found, requires a great deal of work to interpret.   Naturally, Arkady solves the mystery of the book, the whereabouts of many of the characters, and the significance of the meeting.  It's fun to tag along on his journey, both physical and mental.  I kept up with him mentally on some things, but did not on others, but that was part of the fun. For example,
      Also, it was apparently the murder of Anna Politkovskaya that gave Smith the idea for this book.  
    • By SlowRain
      This is the fifth book of Martin Cruz Smith's featuring the cynical, Russian police investigator Arkady Renko. It centers around the apparent suicide of Russia's wealthiest oligarch, who fell 10 stories from his apartment window with a salt shaker in his hand. The investigation takes a twist when a pile of salt is found in his bedroom closet.
      First off, I don't often read mysteries, as I find them to be trite and over the top, with the feeling of being phoned-in rather than thoughtfully-written. Martin Cruz Smith is one of the rare exceptions that I have found (he isn't one of those book-a-year kind of writers). His Arkady Renko stories, and this one is no exception, manage to rise above the simple whodunit, realizing that 'who' isn't as important as the lessons that can be learned from 'why'.
      His strengths are: extremely intricate plots, vivid imagery, and crisp, if somewhat abstract, dialogue. There is never a wasted word, and I have seldom read an author who could say so much in so few words. Every scene has a purpose, and closes with a comment or summation that lets the reader know more was going on than just a conversation. His observations about Russia, crime, and people are all delivered with a note of conviction and finesse.
      My only real complaint about this book would be Arkady's salvation at the climax. I think Mr. Smith is an accomplished enough writer now, and should be able to present a more satisfying climax. However, one small detail can't ruin the brilliant set-up and commentary of the previous several hundred pages.
      Much of this story takes place in the 30km Evacuation Zone surrounding the Chernobyl nuclear facility in Ukraine. Given that April 26, 2006 will be the 20th anniversary of the accident, it is a timely book to read; one that combines actual history with scientific and environmental discussion... and suspense.
      I would heartily recommend this book - as well as his landmark mystery novel, Gorky Park - to anyone who likes well-written thrillers.
    • By tagesmann
      From the back cover:
      Fishing in the Bering Sea, a trawler's nets bring up flatsish, pollock, crabs and a blonde girl in a white blouse and blue jeans. Her name is Zina, and she is a crewmember of the Soviet factory ship Polar Star which processes the American trawlers' cathces.
      Detailed to the ship's "slimeline" where the catch is gutted before freezing, is second-class seaman Arkady Renko, formerly Senior Investigator in the Moscow Prosecutor's Office, now a nobody. But Renko is appointed by the Polar Star's captain to investigate the death.
      This is the second story to feature Arkady Renko and is as good as Gorky Park. During the investigation we learn what happened to Renko after Gorky Park and how he ended up as the lowliest crew member on a fishing boat.
      As the investigation unfolds we discover clues at the same rate as Renko and little is given away. Although initally reluctant to get involved, Renko becomes more drawn into the investigation. He is the same dogged character as before pursuing his on line of enquiry when others would prefer to write the death off as a suicide.
      In one scene when a report is produced by the third officer that suggests an accidental death and recommends that the investigation to be postponed until the ship returns to port.
      Marchuk motioned Arkady closer. "Renko, do you have anything to add?"
      Arkady thought for a moment and said, "No."
      "Then do you want to sign it?"
      "Let's see." Marchuk turned to Arkady. "You disagree with the conclusion that we leave the loose ends for the boys in Vladivostock?"
      "Then with what?"
      "Only . . . " Arkady searched for precision, "the facts."
    • By SlowRain
      Set in Japan, 1941–two days before and the day after the bombing of Pearl Harbor–it tells the story of Harry Niles, an American born, Japanese raised con-man/business owner, as he tries to ward off a possible war between the two countries that he's torn between.
      On the one hand, this is a briskly-paced thriller, always keeping the reader interested, but never entirely sure of what's really going on. On the other, it's a wonderfully atmospheric and evocative picture of 1941 Japan, as well as flashbacks to Harry's youth in the 1920's. Smith, a veteran mystery writer of considerable literary skill, does this credible thriller justice as he spins his intriguing web of deception, revenge, betrayal, and love. It also has one of the most creative, non-clichéd uses of a gun as a plot device that I have ever read.
      The strengths are the well-researched setting, the detailed narrative, the dialogue, and, for the most part, the intriguing plot. I think the weaknesses were the flashbacks, which sometimes interrupted the flow, and a few coincidences with the plot. However, I don't recommend this to a first time Martin Cruz Smith reader as the climax is a little too vintage Smith, and may put some new readers off of a wonderful author. I recommend reading Gorky Park or Rose first.
    • By Binker
      Martin Cruz Smith is another author I actively look for and jump to buy as soon as one of his books comes out. This is the 7th book in his Arkady Renko series, which I think as a group are his strongest books (although his best single book, I think, is Rose).
      This book is short and its unrelated-but-related story lines got resolved pretty quickly, a little more quickly than I would have preferred, but I went with it because I liked the resolution. In fact, I found the last paragraph rather lyrical and I could just see it as it happened. Smith's descriptions of Russian life in general and Moscow life in particular are disturbing. The area around Three Stations is, not surprisingly, full of people who have just arrived in Moscow, often for rather desperate reasons, as well as the predators licking their lips at their arrival. For many of the characters, especially young women and all children, its a desperately unsafe place.
      One of these people is a young woman who is found dead, presumed to be a prostitute who has overdosed. Another is a young prostitute who has fled with her 3 week old daughter to Moscow, only to have her daughter kidnapped by scam artists who want to sell it. Arkady doesn't think the dead girl is a prostitute and he doesn't think she died of an overdose. The story develops from there and eventually weaves in the search for the kidnapped baby.
      Arkady Renko is a good man who feels sorry for the people who are trapped in these terrible sad lives and does what he can to investigate crime even against the will of his corrupt, but successful, boss. And it seems that he does these things at great personal cost. His personal connections are very tenuous and often short-lived, in part because of his job. This noble quality has always been a feature of the Renko books and is one I find appealing. And it certainly appears here, where no one except Renko is very interested in what happens to the people who live in the area.
      The other Renko quality that I find appealing is his ability to look at what everyone else dismisses as meaningless and realize that it is telling a story that he needs to hear and investigate. As I remember, that happened in the first Renko book where he spots some small spots of blood in the snow that many would have ignored (it's possible I'm not remembering it correctly, but I think that's the case). Here, a murder is quite convincingly dressed up as an overdose, but Renko sees small inconsistencies that no one else notices or considers significant, but which turn out to be important.
      I appreciate Martin Cruz Smith's style in these books. In this book, like the others, he doesn't feed you everything you need to understand what is happening, so that you have to work to figure it out. Sometimes, I had to go back and re-read an earlier section to make sense of what I was reading. I think that must be what it is like to participate in an investigation and I appreciate that Smith's books require me to do the work.
      I liked this book and would recommend it if you have read the others in the Arkady Renko series. The books stand alone, so you don't have to read them as a series, but I think that if you can, you should start at the beginning, with Gorky Park and read them in order. Since this is the 7th book in the series, it should be out in paperback by the time you get to it.
  • Create New...