Jump to content

Consider Her Ways and other stories


Tay
 Share

Recommended Posts

I like John Wyndham’s novels, perhaps a little dated in their characters attitudes but the storytelling is strong and inventive. Unfortunately, this selection of stories didn’t quite make the grade for me. The title story is about a time in the future when men have died out and women have survived and found a way to procreate alone. But they have created a caste society limiting the women to certain duties and stations in life. The idea was interesting, but the story was dry and dull. Of the other stories the last one providing an interesting twist on the selling one’s soul to the devil was enjoyable. The others show the seeds of Wyndham’s Sci Fi imagination but felt like early drafts, not quite hitting the mark.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
 Share

  • Similar Content

    • By Bill
      Here is the Amazon link to buy your copy of this month's BGO Book Group choice:
       
      <iframe src="http://rcm-uk.amazon.co.uk/e/cm?t=bookgrouponli-21&o=2&p=8&l=as1&asins=0140013083&fc1=000000&=1&lc1=0000ff&bc1=000000&lt1=_blank&IS2=1&f=ifr&bg1=CCFFFF" width="120" height="240" scrolling="no" marginwidth="0" marginheight="0" frameborder="0">
      </iframe>
       
      If you buy through following this link, a small proportion comes back to us and will help pay for the upkeep of this site. Thanks.
    • By Lizzy Siddal
      Did I misunderstand something?

      I thought that the mutants were punished by being sterilised and abandoned in the fringes to take their chances. So how come spiderman starts entertaining notions of making babies with Rosalind? Surely this would be impossible ....
    • By Ade
      I've just finished reading the novel and am brimming with ideas so thought I'd start a thread.

      Returning to the book as an adult gave me a very different view of it indeed. As a child, I thoroughly enjoyed the tension in the story and empathised with the idea of a group of young people at odds with the alien world around them.

      And as an adult I did enjoy the narrative, but find myself disturbed by some of the ideas. I found myself in sympathy with the novel's message almost all the way through. The idea of a moralistic and religiously bigotted community arising in this post-apocalyptic world was compelling and Wyndham's criticism of this world is very powerful indeed. The use of the innocent narrator works well with this and much of Wyndham's message in the novel's earlier stages - about the need to accept change - is voiced effectively and thoughtfully through Uncle Axel.

      However, it's the final few chapters that disturbed me. The problem with Wyndham's acceptance of the need for evolutionary change comes to have a fascistic resonance for me. The new telepathic race who come to save David and his friends are described as so physically perfect and have such an interest in Petra, as an even more highly evolved member of the species, that I began to doubt them. I was also disturbed by their callous killing of everyone aside from those with powers similar to their own - described as a 'necessity'. I realise that David is also upset by this, but he seems to forget this very quickly as he joins the glorious and bright future (and the writing at this point is all about luminosity and hope). An early liberal message about tolerance and acceptance of others seems to become a harshly fascistic message about a kind of master race who will be ultimately triumphant and eliminate the savages. Shades of 'tomorrow belongs to me', I thought. Very disturbing.

      What do others think? Am I being overly dramatic about this? I certainly had a very different response as an adult and feel a little unsettled by it.
    • By annajane
      I did do a search on this book, & couldn't see this book listed - anyway, hopefully this thread isn't a duplicate.
       
      I have never been especially interested in science fiction, & haven't actually read any up until now. However, I remember seeing The Village Of The Damned years ago & that it was the film version of the Midwich Cuckoos, so when I saw it recently in a charity shop I decided to get it. I haven't been able to put it down!!! I'm half way through it, & don't want it to end - it's great. Great writing, great characterisation, great atmosphere ... I'm very impressed indeed.
       
      Are his other books as good? I may be a sci-fi convert, which I never thought I'd hear myself say!
    • By Mad Dog & Glory
      From the age of 10 till about 14, I was obsessed with the books of John Wyndham. I used to go into libraries and bookshops just to see how many John Wyndham books they had. If it had all of them, it was a good bookshop. If it had none or only a few, it was a bad bookshop. (I had all of them of course.) It was a very simple litmus test, and it worked for me.
       
      I read them over and over again. I loved The Day Of The Triffids of course. Silence being the signifier that something was wrong was very powerful. Chocky - featuring a boy of about my age - meant a lot to me. The Midwich Cuckoos spooked me out completely, but in a good way. My favourite though was The Chrysalids, about a post-apocalyptic world. I can't remember why I loved it so much. Maybe it was because the others were more famous, and we true John Wyndham fans had far more discernment than the hoards!
       
      The books of short stories also had a big effect on me, especially the title story of The Seeds Of Time, about time travel. A lot of mind-expanding thoughts about going forward in time and meeting your future self. It was the first time I came across the concept, which seems to crop up so much now (from Back To The Future to Blackadder), that if you went back in time and changed one small thing, then the present you come back to will be different.
       
      I never read science fiction now. In fact, in my 20s I made the mistake of trying to re-read John Wyndham yet again, but the prose seemed very clunky, and my twentysomething self was intolerant of badly-written prose. I would be more tolerant now.
       
      Nothing though can ever take away the permanent place that John Wyndham has in my childhood.
×
×
  • Create New...